Return to site

Test Limit Philosophy

· test,Test Limits

A lot of times, the test limits used during manufacturing test are identical to the limits in the product's requirements. I strongly advocate against blindly doing this. The manufacturing test limits need to be tied (at least partially) to the actual design intent.

Let's say that marketing wants a circuit board with a resistor divider that divides V_in by two for V_out. Picking numbers out of the air, marketing puts down 5% as the V_out accuracy. Therefore, if V_in is 2V, V_out can be 0.95-1.05V.

The design engineer looks at the specifications and decides to pick resistors that are 1% accurate. If one resistor is +1% and the other resistor is -1% (I'm ignoring temperature effects), then with a 2V input, the output voltage can range from 0.99-1.01V.

And then in manufacturing, what if a 5% resistor gets used? Perhaps, there's a counterfeit part. Perhaps, the wrong reel is loaded. (Don't laugh.) If we had blindly chosen the original 5% tolerance, we would still be within the specification, but likely outside of the design intent of 1%. Even if that original specification is met, we would now be releasing a product that does not match what was used during design verification testing.

In a future post, I'll talk more about taking in the manufacturing test limits further.

All Posts

Almost done…

We just sent you an email. Please click the link in the email to confirm your subscription!

OKSubscriptions powered by Strikingly